Can a buyer and seller close if the seller’s fence encroaches on a neighboring property?
QUESTION: My seller is under contract with Form 2-T and approaching Closing, and the buyer just obtained a survey after the Due Diligence Period ended. Of course, the survey shows that my client’s fence encroaches on the neighbor’s property. The buyer is demanding that the seller move the fence or else they will proceed as if the seller is in breach of contract. My seller does not want to move the fence since it has been there “forever.” How do I handle this?
ANSWER: Depending on the extent of the fence’s encroachment, the buyer may have a good argument that the seller is in breach. Your seller should consult with legal counsel if they are not willing to move the fence.
The Offer to Purchase and Contract (Form 2-T) states:
(g) Good Title, Legal Access: Seller shall execute and deliver a GENERAL WARRANTY DEED for the Property in recordable form no later than Settlement, which shall convey fee simple marketable and insurable title, without exception for mechanics’ liens, lis pendens, monetary liens and judgments, and free of other encumbrances or defects that would materially affect the value of the Property, including those which would be revealed by a current and accurate survey of the Property, except: (i) ad valorem taxes for the current year; (ii) utility easements and unviolated covenants, conditions or restrictions; and (iii) such other liens, encumbrances or defects as may be specifically approved by Buyer in writing. The Property must have legal access to a public right of way. Buyer’s failure to conduct a survey or examine title of the Property, prior to the expiration of the Due Diligence Period does not relieve the Seller of their obligation to deliver good title under this paragraph. (Emphasis added).
In your case, the buyer is not willing to approve the encroachment in writing, but in other cases that may be a good way to solve this issue (subject to the closing attorney being able to certify that the title is fee simple marketable and insurable).
For you, it may be best to start by asking the closing attorney whether they believe the seller can still deliver fee simple marketable and insurable title. If the closing attorney affirms the seller can satisfy those contract terms, then the next question is whether this encroachment “materially affects the value of the property.” There is no black-and-white definition of what this phrase means, but the following is a general guideline for how to think about these issues.
If an encroachment would potentially cause a buyer to incur a significant monetary liability after Closing, then that buyer would probably have good grounds to contend that the encroachment materially affects the property’s value. A seller should understand that the buyer will be stepping into their shoes, and if a neighbor later demands that the buyer remove an encroachment from the neighbor’s property, then the buyer will likely be liable. The seller likely would not be liable, especially in a case like yours, because the buyer has received notice of this encroachment prior to Closing. This means the buyer would be taking the property in its then-existing condition under Form 2-T. Conversely, if an encroachment only very narrowly crosses a property line, and the cost to fix the encroachment is minimal, then the buyer would probably not have very solid grounds to contend that property’s value has been materially affected. It is also unlikely that the seller would not be able to provide fee simple marketable and insurable title given this kind of encroachment.
In your case, it is not clear how extensive the encroachment is, or what the buyer’s potential liability could be post-Closing. If your seller continues to insist they will not fix the fence, then the best course would be to strongly recommend in writing that they seek legal counsel before engaging further with the buyer.
Release Date: 11/19/2026
This article is intended solely for the benefit of NC REALTORS® members, who may reproduce and distribute it to other NC REALTORS® members and their clients, provided it is reproduced in its entirety without any change to its format or content, including disclaimer and copyright notice, and provided that any such reproduction is not intended for monetary gain. Any unauthorized reproduction, use or distribution is prohibited.
